Pizza restaurants

New Pizza Place

4.2 141 reviews Closed 20527 Hollis Ave, Jamaica, NY 11412, United States

Discover this place

New Pizza Place, nestled at 20527 Hollis Ave in Jamaica, NY, stands out as a delightful throwback to classic pizza parlors, evoking a nostalgic feel reminiscent of the ‘90s and early 2000s. Patrons rave about the charming, friendly atmosphere led by the welcoming owner, making every visit feel like a community gathering. Customers can't stop singing the praises of the buffalo pizza, deemed by one enthusiast as “the best pizza I’ve ever experienced in my LIFE.” Its rich flavors, made with fresh ingredients, keep pizza lovers coming back for more. Many reviews highlight the quick service and affordability, making a small cheese pizza a surprise treat that doesn’t break the bank. Diners appreciate the authenticity of New York-style pizza here, which is crafted in batches, ensuring each slice is hot and crispy. Whether you're looking for a casual slice while your car gets fixed, as one happy customer experienced, or just wanting to support a local business over chain restaurants, New Pizza Place delivers consistently. In a world of fast food and chain pizzerias, this cozy establishment reminds us why local spots matter, offering both delicious pizza and a genuine connection to the community.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Seating
Table service

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with New Pizza Place before visiting.

Reviews for New Pizza Place

4.2

141 reviews

100%

45%

20%

Review highlights

Based on 141 reviews

New Pizza Place in Jamaica, NY, is widely praised for its authentic, old-school New York-style pizza that resonates with both nostalgic locals and new customers. Reviewers commonly highlight the freshness and quality of the pizzas, with particular acclaim for specialty options like the buffalo pizza. The establishment is noted for its friendly, welcoming atmosphere and efficient service, often delivering hot, crispy slices quickly. Affordability and support for a small, family-owned business are also recurrent themes, appealing to those seeking a genuine alternative to chain pizzerias. Overall, New Pizza Place is recognized as a reliable choice for flavorful, freshly made pizza with a touch of classic charm.

Kaitlyn Rose

Apr 29, 2025

I didn't feel like cooking so I had dropped by this pizza place and it is very 90s-00s old school fashion. Owner was super kind and friendly. For a small cheese pizza, it was definitely super affordable beyond my expectation and tasty! Pizza was made quickly and it smelled so good on my way home. Forget the chain pizzerias nearby, support local small owned businesses

Colleen Fairweather

Apr 23, 2025

The buffalo pizza is the best pizza I’ve ever experienced in my LIFE !!!!! It’s perfect . Order a buffalo pie you won’t regret it. Pizza is always freshly made batch after batch even if it’s in the window I highly recommend. Did I mention the buffalo pizza is straight GASSSS

Ed POWAZ

Apr 11, 2025

My daughter and I shared a medium Pizza at new pizza and never lets me down. The simple piecef Made Simple. 12 pie. Delicious

Marc Levine

Mar 29, 2025

When I moved here 7 years ago, I looked and found the old school Pizza place of my youth. This is authentic New York Pizz! Leave chain stores behind.

Jessica Smith

Mar 26, 2025

I was parking directly across the street and got a flat. I saw this pizza place and decided to get a slice while I was waiting for it to get fixed. Getting a slice was honestly the best decision I made all day. They accept wireless payment and the pizza was hot and crispy.

Michael Traill

Mar 21, 2025

Best pizza in queens ! Prefer them over a lot of other famous spots !

Shantee Williams

Mar 09, 2025

Everything about them is great. Very patients, order is right and delivery is on time

Mark Gibbs

Mar 01, 2025

I started going to this pizza shop in 2022 & they quickly became my GO TO PIZZA SHOP!!! Being treated with RESPECT & KINDNESS goes a looong way with Me, when I choose a business to spend my hard earned money & the folks at this pizza shop on Hollis Ave. (Nr. Franny Lew) understand that! Salute ...